J's Pizza Market - Mentor, Ohio

The Garden Farmer

Visited J's Pizza Market for the first time and it was a great experience. The place is very clean and quaint...wide open floor plan that allows for a really cool display of the pizza oven, making it the central focus in the entire room!

Comfortable atmosphere and very tentative staff.

The owner is very kind and makes amazing pizzas. There are a BUNCH of styles to choose from and they even offer free slices of some of their more unique pizzas so you can give them a taste test....you'll find that nowhere else.

They got good salads too.

Can't really go wrong here...over all good pizza and kind service.

Francisco Larrondo

"Upon entering this pizza shop, the warm aroma of freshly baked pizza promises an exceptional dining experience. Every slice is a symphony of perfectly crispy crust, rich sauce, and fresh toppings, showcasing a true passion for Italian cuisine.

What truly sets this place apart, though, is the unparalleled service. The staff's warm welcomes and spot-on recommendations make each visit memorable. Their genuine care and enthusiasm create a welcoming atmosphere that feels more like dining among friends.

The heart of this restaurant lies in its people – their kindness and passion for what they do elevate the dining experience to new heights. This pizza shop is a rare find, combining delicious food with excellent service and a friendly vibe. Highly recommended for anyone seeking a fantastic meal in great company."

Rachel Hannon

Solid. Quality ingredients. Love the oven, really like the way you can see the kitchen and see all the action. Cute place. However. For that oven, I expected at least a bit more crunch. I noticed no hot light, my pizza was waiting for me sitting on top of someone else's pizza sitting on the oven. That was a bit odd. Pizza was quality. I can tell there's not ever gonna be a bad day for this pizza, it's good dough, quality cheese, the works. But I didn't really taste much. The sauce was boring, cheese was boring, crust was mid. Therefore, only four star. Definitely try, maybe request extra sauce well done? Love the online ordering system.

Dave Strauss

This use to be good pizza. I went there today and I can’t believe how much they skimmed on toppings and sauce. Very bland tasting go to Pizza Roto 100 times better.

S9424

Their cauliflower crust is the best I’ve found around here. Love that you can do 1/2 and 1/2 on their specialty pizzas!

Kathy Fedorchuk

This place was so good im even leaving a review. The sauce is so tasty, and the cheese is a perfect combo with the sauce. And the crust is amazing too. 10/10 would go again.

Peter Abdalmalek

A great local spot! I love this place, their pizzas are always super fresh and delicious. It's never greasy or oily and just the right crust thickness. All the ingredients are tasty and the end result is just a really good pizza. The staff is always super friendly too which is always a plus! Would definitely recommend!!

Lyndsay Pauler

I had an elderly employee refuse to add extra chicken to a large Native Sun salad. The reason, chicken is too expensive. For real lady? I would expect her to say that it would cost extra, which I was prepared to pay. I have asked for modified orders like this before so whatever bee she had in her bonnet I'll never know. To top it off, the owner John hears the story and then asks what he is supposed to do about it? He sounded pretty incredulous that I would dare expect him to do something about what occurred. I said to him talk to your employee and instruct her in proper customer service. Rude, inconsiderate and unprofessional. This was my last ever visit.